{ "rubricVersion": 3, "phase": "manual-review-draft", "entries": [ { "reviewId": "R001", "runId": "bluebook--claude-haiku-5-5-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列与手机两列错落明确，标题、作者和点赞齐全；图像主要为重复圆形渐变，内容辨识与细节表达有限。", "composition": "四列对齐稳定，卡片高低形成节奏，顶栏紧凑；滚动补图确认后续卡片已加载。", "readability": "标题与数值可辨，搜索提示与头像的浅色对比偏弱，手机卡片信息较密。", "interactionClarity": "搜索与发布入口明确，当前页缺少操作结果状态，不能由按钮推定搜索或发布成功。", "craft": "圆角、间距和配色一致，抽象图形变化较少；先不把画外懒加载占位判为资源故障。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--claude-haiku-5-5-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "25e30a3ea4a1b08620d45c146575d4aca19cd5eafdc00a17f0c82ce8e31ff021", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R002", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-max-r02", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列、手机两列及分类栏完整，标题与作者字段具体；图像为彩色抽象图案，发布与搜索可见。", "composition": "分类、顶栏与卡片区域分层清楚，卡片对齐统一；较高卡片使首屏内容密度稍不均。", "readability": "文本层级清楚，搜索提示及浅色头像偏淡；图案与正文分区容易辨认。", "interactionClarity": "搜索、发布与分类都易找到，选中分类明确；没有据静态截图验证其后续功能。", "craft": "组件、图标与卡片风格统一，滚动后图案继续加载，抽象素材的形状变化仍较有限。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-max-r02.json", "evidenceSetHash": "204f0f43bc961b2ecd6b2299c84232dea25cb5ec26d77e5c264b51a72f3c1120", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R003", "runId": "bluebook--qwen3-8-flash-high-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列和手机两列均可辨，标题、昵称、点赞及红色发布入口齐全；出现明确图片失败回退卡。", "composition": "版心留白和卡片对齐整齐，首屏高低错落自然，补充图显示后续卡片与失败回退状态。", "readability": "标题与数字基本清楚，搜索与作者信息偏小，浅色图案对比温和。", "interactionClarity": "图片回退有明确图标和文字，搜索与发布入口直观；没有把回退画面当成功加载原图。", "craft": "卡片边框与圆角一致，渐变图案重复度较高；保留失败回退这一实际可见状态。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--qwen3-8-flash-high-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "cb861686ed173f36840ebecf32a25bce72adbcc6a903f8d514a444df351bc15c", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R004", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列与手机两列图片流可见，摄影素材、文字头像和点赞完整；发布在手机收为加号，搜索保留。", "composition": "摄影占据主体，列间对齐稳定；个别图片很高，使首屏可浏览卡片偏少。", "readability": "标题、昵称与点赞可辨，搜索占位和次级文字较小，手机摄影与文字分区清楚。", "interactionClarity": "搜索与发布入口清楚，手机加号缺少文字标签；未记录点击后的结果态。", "craft": "摄影裁切自然，白卡与圆角统一；滚动补图显示更多照片，保留重复素材这一可见边界。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "2c0e0ace6564561592d2e75f20bf530c0668fe4d39ff464877f7d5e13b7067a6", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-lower", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R005", "runId": "bluebook--muse-spark-1-3-free-xhigh-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 3, 3, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 4, 2, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列、手机两列均有图片和完整作者字段，但卡片按行齐底，图像高度变化没有形成连续错落瀑布流。", "composition": "图片和卡片对齐整齐，但短图下方大片白区造成行内留白不均，密度与任务的瀑布流节奏不符。", "readability": "正文与摄影内容清楚，作者和点赞字号偏小，层级基本稳定。", "interactionClarity": "搜索与红色发布可辨，缺少当前截图内的搜索或发布结果反馈。", "craft": "摄影素材丰富，组件样式统一；较固定的卡片高度使内容与容器比例不够精细。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--muse-spark-1-3-free-xhigh-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "ff7b02c28a3ddb221173f6e4fa11f3f18a5c9a20c40a2240c13d2d5b430fdc0e", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R006", "runId": "bluebook--claude-opus-5-5-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4, 5, 5, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列桌面与两列手机均形成连续错落布局，语义明确的蛋糕、猫、山景等插画和作者点赞齐备。", "composition": "顶栏、分类与图文卡片层级清楚，列间节奏紧凑，首屏作品密度合理。", "readability": "标题、头像昵称与点赞关系清楚；浅色次级数字和搜索提示仍稍弱。", "interactionClarity": "搜索、分类选中状态与发布主操作明确；没有把这些入口当作完整功能验收。", "craft": "插画具有具体主题，圆角、边界和图标一致；滚动后仍延续同一画风，原尺寸桌面及手机文字清楚。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--claude-opus-5-5-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "3dbcd073804cd71331c697577f2323b99cb3bd8a7c410a0c53dd149bd3c2177f", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R007", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-astra-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 3, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列摄影流和手机两列都清楚，标题、作者、点赞、搜索与发布入口完整，移动发布收在底部加号。", "composition": "侧栏、标题区、分类与摄影卡片分层好；手机标题区域较高，首屏作品展示偏少。", "readability": "照片主体和文字易辨，次级灰字略小；高低图片与作者区域能清楚区分。", "interactionClarity": "分类选中、换一批及发布位置有明确线索，底部加号仍需语义理解；未验证发布后续流程。", "craft": "摄影素材和卡片组件完成较好，图标边距一致；滚动补图呈现更多照片，后续新占位不当作已失败资源。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-astra-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "47c8076b813a78b0551c9b22c4f1e0b9963283afebb345cffdd08c7beb111267", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R008", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r05", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 3, 4, 2, 3, 4, 4, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列和手机两列存在，但卡片按行齐底，白色容器留有大块空区；内容为重复彩色图案。", "composition": "顶栏、分类与底部导航可区分，卡片垂直节奏较机械，固定行高造成图文比例失衡。", "readability": "正文可读但辅助信息偏小，手机加载统计在右侧裁切；抽象图案无法提供具体内容辨识。", "interactionClarity": "推荐标签及加载数量有反馈，发布只以小文字呈现，主操作不够突出。", "craft": "颜色与圆角一致，内部滚动补图显示加载数由四十增至六十；仍有大块行内白区和重复图案。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r05.json", "evidenceSetHash": "f367d6aec011d7c24441244d4e591155a92947153ed2562dc28c8d34978adc87", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R009", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-1-sol-xhigh-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 3, 4, 3, 5, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与两列错落图片流完整，山景、衣物与室内插画语义具体，作者点赞和搜索发布均可辨。", "composition": "标题、分类和作品区层级清楚，留白有秩序；手机标题块偏高，使首屏卡片数量较少。", "readability": "标题与正文清楚，低饱和背景下次级灰字略弱，图片轮廓明确。", "interactionClarity": "选中分类、已收藏与换一组线索具体，搜索和发布易识别；静态图不证明点击结果。", "craft": "插画色系、卡片圆角与边界统一，滚动后更多插画已加载，细节完成较好。" }, "limitations": [ "截图和点击日志只证明已记录状态，不证明全部交互与性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-1-sol-xhigh-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "aaacf64429cac05a92209ee6bc62c1b6968b2507a4b76d129b5805401e42a230", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R010", "runId": "bluebook--deepseek-v4-pro-0813-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 3, 3, 3, 4, 3, 4, 4, 3 ], "visualPoints": [ 3, 3, 3, 2, 3, 3, 4, 3, 4, 2, 3, 2 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列、手机两列可见，但图片高度与卡片高度脱节，未形成连续瀑布流；部分头像资源显示损坏。", "composition": "巨大的卡片空白把图片、标题与作者分开，手机首屏大多被白色空隙占用。", "readability": "文字本身可读，作者及点赞信息太淡，长空白使阅读关联变弱。", "interactionClarity": "搜索及发布入口清楚，点赞图标可辨；资源损坏缺少友好替代。", "craft": "照片有真实内容，滚动后仍保留异常白洞与坏头像，完成度受到明显影响。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--deepseek-v4-pro-0813-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "d4c16642dbf80b0deedbeee6164291aac1ad748d9912232177b76e6d7a1bd95b", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-lower", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R011", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列及手机两列瀑布流完整，图文、文字头像和点赞齐全；图像为多色几何模拟内容。", "composition": "顶栏紧凑，卡片高低错落且间隔一致，滚动后新内容连续衔接。", "readability": "标题容易辨认，次要作者、点赞及搜索提示对比偏弱。", "interactionClarity": "发布与搜索位置稳定，头像及点赞符号可辨；未观察搜索或发布结果。", "craft": "几何图案有多种形状和色彩，卡片组件一致；素材语义与文案关联有限。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "6499c2ad7b7ba6c5445e6d04f8a6135b70ede0dd8ea8431ace530fe31dda9a7e", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-lower", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R012", "runId": "bluebook--claude-haiku-45-default-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 2, 2, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3 ], "visualPoints": [ 3, 3, 4, 3, 3, 4, 4, 3, 3, 4, 3, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面仅三列、手机仅一列，与四列及手机两列要求不符；标题、文字头像和点赞仍齐全。", "composition": "桌面内容区很窄且留白过多，卡片排成整齐行，瀑布流的错落关系不明显。", "readability": "标题偏粗但可辨，窄列造成频繁折行，点赞信息颜色较淡。", "interactionClarity": "搜索、发布入口清楚；动态加载后的卡片可见，未证明具体操作结果。", "craft": "摄影素材清晰多样，圆角和头像一致，但布局响应与密度明显不足。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--claude-haiku-45-default-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "f11a1ad0ea07948ca099b8a141bb2d8d1319f28dfce7b8450f323f55156a4bf6", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R013", "runId": "bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-0731-high-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列、手机两列连续瀑布流，标题、头像及点赞完整；图像为带尺寸文字的模拟山形渐变。", "composition": "顶栏与内容分层稳定，列间距统一，滚动后卡片持续填充。", "readability": "标题清楚，图片内小字及作者点赞信息偏淡，手机长标题折行较密。", "interactionClarity": "搜索和发布入口醒目，未依据入口推定搜索及发布完成。", "craft": "卡片圆角和多色头像一致，模拟图重复山形与圆形，素材内容细节有限。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-0731-high-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "c77b80f1f97a33922f8de2a038af78729e09e5ab8b407abc58249711a912adbb", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R014", "runId": "bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-1017-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列、手机两列瀑布流明确，多种相机、服装、餐具图形带来可辨的模拟内容，字段齐全。", "composition": "发现标题、计数与卡片层次明确，手机顶栏紧凑，滚动后排布保持连续。", "readability": "标题清晰，次要作者与提示颜色偏浅，手机卡片文字密度略高。", "interactionClarity": "发布加号、搜索和当前加载计数明确，计数在滚动补图中发生变化。", "craft": "图形与分类相关且色调统一，圆角、标签、头像细节协调，图像仍属简化插画。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-1017-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "98baba9273143e762a2d6c17d1b652f612aeb2f54360f73061d5d191f268e43b", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R015", "runId": "bluebook--deepseek-v4-pro-0813-high-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 3, 2, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列和手机两列错落成立，图文与点赞完整；作者头像多处损坏，部分图像区未显示内容。", "composition": "首屏卡片紧凑有节奏，滚动后出现空白图片槽，视觉连续性下降。", "readability": "标题清晰，作者点赞较小；坏头像图标增加信息噪声。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布入口可辨，资源缺失缺少友好反馈，未观察到其他操作结果。", "craft": "照片题材丰富但与标题未必对应，圆角一致；两轮采集均出现坏头像，素材可靠性不足。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--deepseek-v4-pro-0813-high-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "a9a2734d839f68d972e35559860bda41d4ca2820592292d8fbe04cd015e8e768", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R016", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-sol-medium-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列、手机两列，滚动后错落排列明确，图文、作者和点赞齐备；模拟图样式较重复。", "composition": "顶栏、标题、分类清楚，初始首行齐平，补充图显示更明显的瀑布流；手机分类换行占位偏大。", "readability": "主体文字可读，搜索被压缩，手机分类标签在词内折行影响扫读。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布及刷新入口明确，分类有选中态，未观察发布或筛选结果。", "craft": "配色柔和、组件一致，图片反复使用太阳和波浪，内容表现细节偏少。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-sol-medium-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "ccb08ab9b875951c8ca0e1bee5df5213b59e32259b2bc7c27befbbd337e93fbf", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R017", "runId": "bluebook--claude-4-0-unknown-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列连续瀑布流，照片内容丰富，作者、标题和点赞状态完整。", "composition": "顶栏克制，首屏内容密度合适，补充滚动后仍保持连续列排布。", "readability": "主体文本清楚，手机作者名被省略，点赞与次要文字仍偏小。", "interactionClarity": "发布搜索容易发现，点赞的空心与实心状态区分明显，不能由已有状态断言点击成功。", "craft": "照片清晰，头像与卡片细节一致，部分文案与摄影题材不完全对应。" }, "limitations": [ "历史后续多轮输入与上下文未完整保留，按已存任务正文及现有页面判断。", "截图只证明已记录状态，不证明搜索、发布等完整操作成功。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--claude-4-0-unknown-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "8e2ff22ce5062a0ac089370f905880ac109f5870271b9bcb7ec43e3e02754c21", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R018", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-1-sol-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流，照片、头像、作者及点赞齐全，分类搜索发布都有入口。", "composition": "绿色引导横幅与摄影卡片协调，但手机首屏横幅和顶栏占据较多空间。", "readability": "标题清楚，绿色次要文案及小号作者文字对比偏弱，照片主体明确。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布位置明确，分类当前态可辨；补充截图证明更多图片已加载。", "craft": "照片裁切和卡片圆角统一，字体层级细腻，图片内容重复但没有将新占位直接判作故障。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-1-sol-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "fef40f3bfe963e71357356228c5364aecbaf8033c6c452f41096ce0d70a3c4f8", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R019", "runId": "bluebook--gemini-3-8-flash-high-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流完整，照片、作者、点赞齐全；标题文案与照片主题有明显错位。", "composition": "顶栏与卡片紧凑，列高差异自然，长标题略压缩内容密度。", "readability": "主要文字清晰，手机长标题截断较多，点赞与作者次要信息偏小。", "interactionClarity": "搜索、发布入口清楚，点赞位置稳定，没有操作结果证据。", "craft": "摄影素材清晰且卡片统一，重复使用有限照片，内容与标题对应关系不足。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gemini-3-8-flash-high-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "d904e5875a47604fbe3e1c63216f50d6890752ec9d7d184de1f255e68c756c5e", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R020", "runId": "bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-1017-high-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列和手机两列错落明确，标题作者点赞完整，图片为重复渐变几何模拟图。", "composition": "分类和卡片层次清楚，移动分类横排保留密度，滚动后新图加载连贯。", "readability": "主体文字清楚，小号作者与搜索提示偏淡，模拟图中的细线不承担关键信息。", "interactionClarity": "发布、搜索、分类和加载更多入口明确，当前分类及加载计数有可见反馈。", "craft": "组件一致，卡片圆角与头像协调，图案虽色彩变化丰富但形状重复较多。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-1017-high-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "37eb43ac14cfc50ffdd8f3b710a0211bedc7a78be8f810c1fda0517fb2d40209", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R021", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-max-r02", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 3, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 3, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流成立，文字头像点赞齐全；主体图片多数是标题加渐变色块，内容图像表现有限。", "composition": "顶栏紧凑、列对齐稳定，标题图片和正文标题重复占用空间。", "readability": "正文可读，部分白色图中文字在亮黄色背景上对比偏弱，次要字较小。", "interactionClarity": "搜索和发布入口可辨，点赞图标位置一致，缺少已执行结果状态。", "craft": "多色卡片样式一致，但模拟图片主要依赖大字和简单装饰，素材细节不足。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-max-r02.json", "evidenceSetHash": "4178c95d3e01b6117d52fceb25077efb97e9395a763d3210451491d3e66dbf47", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R022", "runId": "bluebook--longcat-25-preview-free-default-r01", "status": "insufficient", "taskPoints": null, "visualPoints": null, "captureState": "initial", "confidence": "low", "reason": "桌面、手机及滚动补充截图均未显示页面主体，无法判断任务完成情况。", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四帧均为空白背景，未显示卡片或页面主体，不能据此给任务分。", "composition": "画面没有可判定的内容组织，无法评价布局完成情况。", "readability": "截图没有可读界面文字，不能推定实际文本可读性。", "interactionClarity": "截图未显示可辨操作入口，无法判断交互表达。", "craft": "没有实际素材或组件细节可复核，保留证据不足状态。" }, "limitations": [ "未显示主体的空白页只标记证据不足，不从源码或历史评分补造分数。", "历史系统提示与完整会话上下文未保留。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--longcat-25-preview-free-default-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "0bb33f9462180f2b9a8a6858dddb85990251df137a90b5803ad38474e78a2182", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R023", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-luna-max-r02", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5, 5, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流完整，照片与文字主题对应，作者点赞以及搜索发布均可辨。", "composition": "侧栏、分类和卡片分区清楚，手机收起侧栏后内容密度合适。", "readability": "标题清晰，作者及点赞字号偏小、颜色偏淡，图像主体清楚。", "interactionClarity": "发布搜索刷新及选中分类明确，补充图显示更多图片加载后的状态。", "craft": "照片素材多样且裁切协调，组件与配色统一；部分次要文字仍可加强。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-luna-max-r02.json", "evidenceSetHash": "64b1ea5fbfffe2556a6e6743c03201e2ac5380364afed21e930b53f4f9851052", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R024", "runId": "bluebook--longcat-25-preview-free-default-r02", "status": "insufficient", "taskPoints": null, "visualPoints": null, "captureState": "initial", "confidence": "low", "reason": "桌面与手机初始图以及两张滚动补图均为空白，未呈现可评分主体。", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四帧没有呈现内容卡片，不能判断任务覆盖情况。", "composition": "空白背景没有可复核的布局主体，无法给构图分数。", "readability": "没有实际界面文字可读，不能从预期设计推测表现。", "interactionClarity": "未观察可辨认的搜索、发布或其他操作入口。", "craft": "没有可视素材和组件细节，不能依据原有总分补算。" }, "limitations": [ "页面主体未展示，保留真实空白证据并标记 insufficient。", "原始系统提示和完整会话上下文未保留。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--longcat-25-preview-free-default-r02.json", "evidenceSetHash": "e2d4b2ec763cc258b6d274d2ab754a34ea44ea8143d8a35a66a8a9a6ae870605", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R025", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r04", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 3, 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 3, 4, 2, 3, 4, 4, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列可见，但卡片以整行等高排列并留有白洞，瀑布流表达不足；模拟图重复较多。", "composition": "桌面卡片间距稳定，内部滚动后出现成行空图卡，图片与文字密度不连续。", "readability": "标题可读，手机右上计数被裁切，次要文字和图中文字偏小。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布和底部导航可辨，滚动后加载数有变化，发布文字入口较弱。", "craft": "多色山形图保持一致，但重复与空图卡降低细节完成度。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r04.json", "evidenceSetHash": "384c50a48316f6616cf87138921c2cc70606db20ac8dc2a120f3c9250dcfaafd", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R026", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-1-sol-medium-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 3, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列排布完整，标题作者点赞齐全；相邻列反复出现相同山形图和标题，内容变化不足。", "composition": "顶栏、标题及分类明确，手机分类换行与顶部留白偏多，补图后的列排布连续。", "readability": "标题清楚，小号英文提示、作者及搜索提示对比偏弱。", "interactionClarity": "搜索、发布和换一批入口明确，当前分类可辨，未验证换批或发布结果。", "craft": "圆角及配色协调，但图形和文案成对重复，内容素材细节有限。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-1-sol-medium-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "f7f2ffd902f960687c397ca2f8c6079fab8c0e7be1dbfcb15b20a6c5f7a9afc6", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R027", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m2-unknown-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 2, 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列瀑布流清楚，手机为单列，未满足手机两列；照片、标题作者和点赞完整。", "composition": "桌面卡片连续错落，手机大图占用首屏，单屏只能浏览很少内容。", "readability": "标题易读，标签和作者小字偏淡，首屏摄影主体清楚。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布可辨，点赞评论分享符号齐全，仅证明入口与已有状态。", "craft": "照片、标签和卡片细节一致，手机响应规则不足，历史多轮上下文缺失。" }, "limitations": [ "历史后续多轮输入和参考资料未完整保留，仅按存档任务及页面评分。", "截图未验证搜索发布或其他完整交互结果。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m2-unknown-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "0392b34dda0a983d1e07880c0b363cc2c29ee58d04c282af0c33f3abacd6fec1", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R028", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 4, 4, 3, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 3, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列与手机两列可见，但初始图片等高、错落较弱；主要图像为渐变标题块，文字头像点赞齐全。", "composition": "对齐和间距稳定，补充图显示部分列高变化，首屏瀑布流节奏仍不明显。", "readability": "正文标题清楚，亮色图片上的白字及次要信息对比偏弱。", "interactionClarity": "搜索和发布入口易辨，点赞位置稳定，未观察后续结果状态。", "craft": "组件保持一致，但图片重复标题与简单几何装饰，缺少内容素材细节。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "bd842e68d42f0b8563fc6ceafacc1e39b49efdc5ac60ea1f30745c5ef0fafdfc", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R029", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r03", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流明确，照片作者点赞齐全；摄影内容与部分标题不对应。", "composition": "顶栏紧凑，照片高低形成连续节奏，补图显示懒加载后更多真实照片。", "readability": "标题可读，小字号作者点赞较淡，手机标题折行较密。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布清楚，点赞符号明确，未观察操作结果或错误反馈。", "craft": "照片丰富、裁切清楚，卡片边界较朴素，图文语义对应与细节可继续改善。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r03.json", "evidenceSetHash": "a94a8a2515f602d4914968d818c6afa47a5686fe2bd75ad28e7a8b24d3eab28b", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R030", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-5-6-luna-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 4, 2, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流可见，图文头像点赞齐全；手机首屏未见发布入口。", "composition": "标题区和卡片排布稳定，部分首行齐平；补充图显示后续高低差，手机顶栏布局偏挤。", "readability": "标题清楚，作者及英文编号偏淡，搜索在手机宽度下挤占顶栏空间。", "interactionClarity": "桌面发布、搜索与刷新明确，手机发布不可见；点赞有重复入口但未证明操作结果。", "craft": "柔和色调、圆角及头像一致，图片以重复太阳波浪为主，内容细节有限。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-5-6-luna-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "4ca570ddd593f397c60cf25f4d52e7d44a574d98de5ab0e63e82c17733241556", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R031", "runId": "bluebook--gpt-6-astra-xhigh-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 5, 4, 5, 4, 5 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 5, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 5, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流完整，照片、标题、作者和点赞齐全，分类搜索发布明确。", "composition": "标题分类与卡片分层清楚，滚动后列排布连续；手机顶部留白与分类换行占用较多空间。", "readability": "标题清楚，作者点赞较淡，主体照片可辨，手机长标题有折行。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布换一批及分类当前态明确，补充图证明更多图片加载，未证明所有操作有效。", "craft": "摄影素材、圆角和头像协调，照片内容有重复但整体细节稳定。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--gpt-6-astra-xhigh-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "0b5abf44a200e9e69b94077fb16f7bd6260aaefcfbb383c83f400073a772cd92", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R032", "runId": "bluebook--qwen3-8-max-xhigh-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 3, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列可见，补图显示列高变化；图片为高大几何模拟图，标题作者点赞完整。", "composition": "初始第一行大图齐平，首屏密度偏低，滚动补图才显现错落排布。", "readability": "文字可读但很小，作者和搜索提示偏淡，几何图像易辨但缺少语义细节。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布位置清楚，点赞入口一致，未观察操作结果。", "craft": "卡片圆角和头像一致，几何素材重复较多，长图占比与内容密度有改善空间。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--qwen3-8-max-xhigh-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "f17d2d1ad4a7794a9782daf7dc0939bc8dcb685e37f285de004959f7c4087fb3", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R033", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r02", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列及手机两列瀑布流完整，摄影、标题、文字头像和点赞齐全；个别标题与照片主题不对应。", "composition": "照片错落连续，桌面首屏大图占比较高，手机仍可顺序浏览多张卡片。", "readability": "标题清楚，作者点赞较淡，部分卡片文字与作者间空白稍多。", "interactionClarity": "搜索与发布入口易辨，滚动补图显示更多图片已加载，未验证其他操作。", "craft": "摄影素材清晰多样，卡片与头像统一；重复内容及图文对应关系限制精细度。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-preview-max-r02.json", "evidenceSetHash": "f4ae9db0d8cedad1dc4ad0280fe13e69bb3d654546fbeee030b63c766f651e3b", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-lower", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R034", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m2-1-unknown-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "桌面四列与手机两列瀑布流完整，照片、文字头像及点赞齐全；多处标题与图片语义不符。", "composition": "卡片紧凑错落，首屏信息密度合适，滚动后新增内容连续。", "readability": "标题清晰，次要作者和点赞数字偏小，摄影主体明确。", "interactionClarity": "搜索与加号入口可辨，发布只用浅色加号表达，未观察发布结果。", "craft": "照片清晰多样，圆角和头像统一，但随机文案与图片对应不足。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m2-1-unknown-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "7a7e231413eb9e2fed564fb428a4351afb720c541260e89408ad7282bb10007e", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R035", "runId": "bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-0731-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列错落明确，标题、头像作者点赞齐全；图像为简单山形和圆形模拟素材。", "composition": "顶栏紧凑、卡片列对齐稳定，滚动后仍有可见空图槽，连续性有所下降。", "readability": "标题可读，作者及搜索提示偏淡，图片内名称较小且主题辨识度有限。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布入口清楚，点赞符号统一，图片空槽没有明确状态说明。", "craft": "颜色和卡片风格一致，素材重复较多，补图中仍有首屏空图区域。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--deepseek-v4-1-flash-0731-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "f5a6152224483ca82a37c9b339bbf88899f356842848b16c05a840c519e9e3eb", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R036", "runId": "bluebook--claude-sonnet-5-5-medium-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列及手机两列瀑布流完整，标题、作者、文字头像与点赞齐全；图像为重复气泡渐变并含明确失败替代图。", "composition": "卡片错落清楚，部分图片过高压低首屏信息密度，错误占位仍保留布局位置。", "readability": "标题清楚，作者及搜索提示偏淡；错误文字可辨，图片主体语义有限。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布易辨，失败图片有图标和文字反馈，不能把替代图当作成功图片内容。", "craft": "圆角、头像和配色一致，气泡形态重复，细节与内容素材变化有限。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--claude-sonnet-5-5-medium-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "109668e630301383914b10bbb73e78f4c4124cc642d8327de8c9d893a35d000a", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R037", "runId": "bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-max-r03", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列瀑布流明确，标题、文字头像与点赞齐备；模拟图主要为标题加圆形渐变。", "composition": "卡片高低形成节奏，但高图片压缩首屏信息密度，补充图里仍有空图槽。", "readability": "标题清楚，次要作者及搜索提示偏淡，图片内文字与正文有重复。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布入口清楚，空图缺少明确反馈，未观察其他操作结果。", "craft": "卡片和标签一致，多色渐变细节稳定，但素材语义及空槽处理不足。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--minimax-m3-1-flash-max-r03.json", "evidenceSetHash": "e7fa26a77cf8987aeedd1c3330e531371f7648bc6b61e7b2a10a4f52e0c95070", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R038", "runId": "bluebook--mimo-v2-6-flash-free-max-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 4, 5, 3, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列与手机两列可见，卡片错落较弱且重复图文较多；作者点赞完整，有加载失败替代。", "composition": "排布规整紧凑，整体更接近重复行列，部分空图槽破坏连续浏览。", "readability": "标题可读，作者及搜索提示较淡，图像为简化圆形和短线而非具体题材。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布清楚，失败图标有说明，不能把该占位当作成功图片。", "craft": "圆角与头像一致，但模拟素材变化小，补图仍出现首屏空槽。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--mimo-v2-6-flash-free-max-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "8b79af1172a6bbc79ea24dc1dfefe719d25ea71c16a78f262e03f3b5d410d73d", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true }, { "reviewId": "R039", "runId": "bluebook--kimi-k3-high-r01", "status": "rated", "taskPoints": [ 5, 5, 5, 4, 4, 5, 4, 4 ], "visualPoints": [ 4, 4, 5, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 4, 3 ], "captureState": "result", "confidence": "medium", "observations": { "taskCoverage": "四列及手机两列瀑布流成立，照片、作者和点赞完整，部分照片与标题主题不对应。", "composition": "顶栏紧凑，错落排布连续，手机标志被挤成两行影响整齐度。", "readability": "标题清楚，作者及点赞较小，摄影主体可辨，手机标题换行稍密。", "interactionClarity": "搜索发布明确，点赞位置一致，补充图显示更多真实图片已经加载。", "craft": "照片与卡片细节稳定，头像颜色统一；标志换行和图文语义错位限制完成度。" }, "limitations": [ "截图及采集日志只证明已记录状态，不证明完整交互、实现算法或性能。" ], "captureManifest": "catalog/screenshot-captures/2026-10-21-scroll/bluebook--kimi-k3-high-r01.json", "evidenceSetHash": "ac4e6c98db64c75b4b8bc1236a16881dba5d938bbcbf726a8e5d55f036e22eae", "reviewedFrames": [ "desktop-initial", "desktop-full", "mobile-initial", "desktop-scrolled-full", "desktop-scrolled-top" ], "supplementReviewed": true } ] }